Amazon Fire Phone vs. Nexus 5

Before Amazon announced the Fire Phone, many suspected that it would carry budget pricing – a la the Kindle Fire line of tablets. Well, that wasn’t the case. But does Amazon’s handset offer anything over one of the best smartphone values around, the Nexus 5? Let’s compare the two phones’ features and specs.


The Fire Phone is 4 percent narrower and 3 percent thicker than the Nexus 5

Sizes are closer than you might expect. The Fire Phone is a hair taller than the Nexus 5, while measuring 4 percent narrower and 3 percent thicker. The big difference is that the Nexus 5’s screen takes up a much higher portion of its face.


The Nexus 5 is 19 percent lighter

The Fire Phone is no lightweight, tipping the scales at 23 percent heavier than the feathery Nexus 5.


The Fire Phone has a glass back, while the Nexus 5's is made of plastic

Part of that weight discrepancy can be chalked up to the Fire Phone’s glass back. That’s something we haven’t seen much of since the days of the iPhone 4/4s, LG Optimus G and Nexus 4.


The Fire Phone is only being sold in a black color option, while the Nexus 5 has three opt...

You can now buy the Nexus 5 in three color options, while the Fire Phone only comes in black.

Display (size)

The Fire Phone gives you 90 percent as much screen real estate as the Nexus 5

Despite being the slightly taller phone, the Fire Phone only gives you 90 percent as much screen as the Nexus 5 does.

Display (resolution)

The Nexus 5 has the much sharper display

This is probably the most disappointing spec in the Fire Phone. 315 pixels per inch should look pretty sharp, but it isn’t going to compare with the ultra-crisp 1080p screens that we’ve seen on recent phones like the Galaxy S5, HTC One and, yes, the Nexus 5.

3D display

The Fire Phone has a 'Dynamic Perspective' 3D display

Amazon is avoiding the word “3D” like the plague, probably because the term has been associated with so many consumer electronics bombs. But the Fire Phone’s “Dynamic Perspective” technology creates a glasses-free 3D effect nonetheless, giving developers a new (and gimmicky?) tool to play with.

Image recognition

Amazon's Firefly feature scans your environment and recognizes things like QR codes, web U...

The Fire Phone’s other big feature is called Firefly. Press the dedicated Firefly button, scan something in your environment and watch as the Fire Phone processes it. It can work for things like QR codes, email addresses and web URLs, but Amazon is hoping you’ll also use it to scan products. Those scanned consumer items will be immediately added to your Amazon shopping cart (so kind of you, Amazon).


The Fire Phone's Fire OS is a Google-free version of Android, which means you won't get th...

I’d say this category is the Nexus 5’s killer feature, and likely the Fire Phone’s Achilles’ heel. The Nexus runs the purest form of Android 4.4 KitKat, just as Google intended it. It’s a user-friendly and straightforward UI, without all the bloat and extraneous features that OEMs and carriers like to add onto most Android phones.

The Fire Phone, meanwhile, has you moving your smartphone business into Amazonville. Unlike the Nexus 5, you don’t get the excellent Google Play Store for your app needs. In fact, you don’t get a single Google app. Instead all your software will come from the Amazon Appstore, which has built up a decent collection in its three years of existence, but still isn’t in the same league as the Play Store.

On-device customer support

The Fire's Mayday button gives you one-way video chat with an Amazon rep right on your dev...

Amazon’s Mayday button is probably the biggest consumer tech support innovation since Apple’s Genius Bar. Tap a button on the Fire Phone’s screen and watch as an Amazon rep pops up in a little video chat box on your screen. He or she can only hear you (and draw on your screen, if you wish), but you’ll get both video and audio on your end.


Storage options

The Fire Phone has higher storage tiers, but, as we’ll see in a minute, you’ll be paying for it.


Both phones have speedy Snapdragon 800 processors inside

The Nexus 5 is a very fast phone and the Fire Phone should be too, with the speedy Snapdragon 800 on board.


Both phones have 2 GB of RAM

Both phones also carry 2 GB of RAM.


On paper, the Fire Phone's camera is looking good, but you can only draw so many conclusio...

The Nexus 5 has a serviceable camera, but I also wouldn’t say it’s one of its best features. The Fire Phone’s rear shooter looks good on paper, but we’ll have to wait before jumping to conclusions about its quality.


The Fire has a slightly higher-capacity battery

Ditto for battery life, as we’ll have to put the Fire Phone’s slightly higher-capacity battery to the test before closing this book. Considering it’s powering a lower-resolution screen, though, we’d bet on it providing some solid uptimes.


The Fire Phone is set to launch on July 25

Fire Phone preorders are set to deliver on July 25. The Nexus 5 is hardly a spring chicken, having been available since last October.

Starting price (off-contract)

Off-contract, the Nexus 5 costs US$300 less than the Fire Phone

If you live in the US, then you can snag the Fire Phone for US$200 on-contract. But that’s only $150 less than what the Nexus 5 will cost you off-contract. One perk is that Amazon is throwing in a free year of Amazon Prime for Fire Phone buyers, though it’s still hard to argue that it’s going to provide the better value here.

But, again, it’s way too early to jump to conclusions about the Fire Phone. Just looking at these specs and features, it might look a bit like an overpriced bag of gimmicks with an inferior app selection, but until we get some extended hands-on time and publish our full review, we’re going to keep an open mind about this bold new flagship.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s